Wednesday, September 24, 2014

Best Banned Books

Happy Banned Books Week y'all! It's time to celebrate all the great stories that curmudgeons deem unsuitable for public consumption. As far as weird holidays go I'd rank this as better than Talk Like a Pirate Day but not yet at Saint Patrick's Day levels.

Last year's most frequently banned books included these gems:

2013. Reasons: Offensive language, racism, sexually explicit, unsuited for age group

This is an amazing book. 
The protagonist leaves the reservation to get a better education at the white school. Of course the book has offensive language and racism. How could it avoid that without candy coating the story? A realistic, flawed, and deeply relatable teenage boy tells the story in his own words--so of course it's sexually explicit. Adolescence is a time when we're all keenly aware and interested in sex.
Alexie  doesn't pull any punches, he lets you really get into this kid's head, which is probably why this book is banned.  Whenever someone writes about what it's really like to be a teenager, the book is always deemed "unsuited for age group."

2013. Reasons: Religious viewpoint, unsuited to age group

I haven't read this series in a while, so I can't recall why someone might have a religious objection to it. However, I can understand why some find this series unsuitable for children. There's the whole "I don't support children killing children" point of view and I respect that. However, I think this book is valuable for young readers. Lots of books play on our fear of death, this book asks us to think about how we'd feel if we were asked to kill. You might survive the hunger games, but think of the terrible things you'd have to do. The violence itself is as frightening and repugnant as death. Ultimately, the protagonist wins through a subversive act of pacifism. 

Sadly, I haven't read the other banned books of 2013 so I can't vouch for their excellence. However, I will mention a few more great books. All of these were in the top ten most frequently challenged for their year.

2012. Reasons: Homosexuality, offensive language, religious viewpoint, sexually explicit



2011. Reasons: insensitivity; nudity; racism; religious viewpoint; sexually explicit. 
You know it's a great book when it's decades old and people are still angry about it.


2011. Reasons: offensive language; racism
When you ban an anti-racism book for racism you are missing the point.


2007. Reason: racism


2007. Reason: sexually explicit


2003. Reasons: occult/Satanism


Each of these books have made me a better person. Each of them has taught me something valuable. I think that the reason why so many people dislike these books can best be explained by Gloria Steinem "The truth will set you free, but first it will piss you off."
Happy Banned Books Week everyone. 

Wednesday, September 10, 2014

Everything I Know About Pregnancy I Learned from Television

Most of what I knew about pregnancy came from television and movies. I never believed that I would one day be an actual adult in an actual marriage having actual babies so I didn’t make an effort to educate myself. However, I was always a media-savvy kid so I picked up quite a bit about the miracle of life through pop culture. There are three ways this can go down.

 Totes Adorbs Comedy
 We start with our protagonist vomiting into the toilet. In the next scene we jump to footage of the woman putting her hand over her stomach as the mystical realization dawns on her I’m going to be a mother. This pregnancy will no doubt come as a complete shock, maybe she never wanted kids, but eventually she rallies and decide that she’s up to the challenge.
Then it’s time to tell the partner. He’s probably a boyfriend who’s not sure if he’s ready for the responsibility/ a loving husband who will probably die. If the woman doesn’t have a suitable partner at the beginning of the film she’ll find one by the end because movies aimed at women MUST include a romantic arc. Nevermind that she’s uncomfortable and grumpy and doesn’t have time to pursue a relationship, somehow she  finds true love.
Pregnancy romance is a real genre. People buy these books. On purpose.
This partner frets constantly about her health while making a 2AM grocery trip to buy bizarre combinations of junk food. By now the film has skipped straight to the dramatic third trimester so they can show her being huge and “cute.” Also, the audience learns of a major event looming on the horizon like a big business meeting or an emotionally fraught family reunion. If there is no such event foreshadowed then you can expect someone to die, emphasizing the connection between birth and death.
The woman attends a birthing class, hijinks ensue. Something trivial like a mistaken coffee order will make her completely lose it in public. Her personal and professional relationships start to unravel.
Never fear, the big foreshadowed event arrives and it’s her chance to fix whatever’s broken in her life. But oh no! Her water broke at the worst possible moment.  Her loved ones gather around her and whisk her off to the hospital and all is forgiven.
The delivery itself features glass shattering screams and demonic moans. She will inevitably yell to her partner “You did this to me!”  She carries on until every girl in the audience vows to never bear children.
Then it’s over! a beautiful, clean, three month old baby is placed in the mother’s arms. In that tender moment her personal and plot conflicts are all resolved as she realizes that her life will never be the same again. Having a baby fixes everything. Roll credits.

So that’s the happy and normal portrayal of pregnancy and birth. Cutesy and totally disconnected from reality, but at least it puts a positive spin on things. At least it’s not…

Gritty and Inspirational
 The expectant mother is probably a teenager, or homeless, or dating an abusive drug addict. Either way she’s in trouble. Her partner kicks her out, her family provides zero help, but she may have some helpful girlfriends to give sassy-yet-insightful advice.

 She decides not to have an abortion because then we don’t have our inspirational pregnancy story. She considers adoption, but the writers want this to be super-extra inspiring so the woman decides against all odds that she’s keeping her baby. She doesn’t have a steady job or access to childcare but all she needs is love. Lucky for her, this is a movie.

At first she struggles to survive on the streets. The audience sees her gradually make some responsible choices like talking with a social worker or interviewing for minimum wage jobs. Heart wrenching setbacks precede heroic efforts until she’s almost cobbled together a stable life for her unborn child. But wait! At the last moment her sure-thing-perfect job falls through and now the social worker can’t help her.

Now that everything is awful again the woman gives birth. Screams, drama, pain...really emphasize that pain. Once again the beautiful, clean, three month old baby is placed in her arms. Help comes from an unexpected quarter and fixes her financial problems. Everything is going to be ok and she knows that her life has been changed forever. The end.

 While that pregnancy story is terrible, it’s nothing compared to…

Mystical Pregnancy in Speculative Fiction
The chosen hero foretold in prophecy ain’t gonna gestate himself. The woman likely got pregnant through magic, mad science, or midichlorians. If not then the father is royalty or has some supernatural power. Occasionally that supernatural father is literally the devil, setting up the story for some demon baby horror.

If the “father” is human or some benevolent force then the woman will probably struggle through a long and difficult pregnancy all alone and gives birth to our hero in the desert. If she doesn’t die tragically in childbirth then she’ll probably kick the bucket early in her son’s lifetime so that he can be raised by monks or wizards.

If the “father” is essentially evil then lookout. The pregnancy itself might take only a few days, giving the woman no time to prepare for her precious bundle of supernatural joy. If the baby is evil then the heroes kill it, if it’s benign then a plot device will come and make it disappear.  Either way the whole process of pregnancy and birth will be disgusting, life-threatening, and completely out of the woman’s control. Not to worry though, this is just a throw-away episode, next time we see her she’s recovered emotionally and her abs and flat once more. 

Well...that’s a special kind of awful.

My Reality
Obviously some pregnancy stories are better than others. Yet even the over-the-top saccharine  comedies show pregnancy as this out of control experience that ends in unbelievable pain. It’s something that happens to women, not something that women do. It’s a small but significant difference. When you do something you have power. When something happens to you then you’re just a passive victim of biology. Sorry honey, take it up with God.

But that’s a lie.

My pregnancy is so much better than expected. Yes. I’m unusually emotional, desperately tired, and ravenously hungry. But I chose this. I’m in charge of this process. When I watch real-life birthing videos I see women who are doing something that hurts, something hard. But they’re doing it. The action comes from strength not helplessness. 

This isn’t an endorsement of natural childbirth, and it isn’t a condemnation of Hollywood. It’s just a reminder that pregnancy is like the rest of life--so much better than television told us it would be.

sources: